Everybody's Records at 6106 Montgomery Road in Cincinnati's Pleasant Ridge neighborhood is the Queen City's longest-running independent record store. Opened in 1978, the shop has operated continuously for nearly five decades, outlasting the CD revolution, the format collapse of the 1990s and 2000s, and the streaming era that buried most of its peers. It is the kind of neighborhood record store that has watched generations of Cincinnati music fans grow up pulling records out of the same bins, and the kind of shop that serious collectors visit weekly because the trade-ins turn the inventory over faster than new arrivals alone ever could.
For readers who dug our Cincinnati area guide, Everybody's is the long-running heritage anchor alongside Shake It Records in Northside (1999), Feel It Records in Clifton, and Plaid Room Records in Loveland. Cincinnati collectors know the four shops form a complete circuit; Everybody's is the one with the deepest accumulated history.
47 Years on Montgomery Road
Everybody's Records opened its doors in 1978, the same year the vinyl industry peaked at its all-time sales high of roughly 341 million LPs shipped in the U.S. The shop was founded in the pre-CD era, operated through the 1980s as cassettes grew, through the 1990s as CDs took over, and survived the 2000s vinyl near-extinction when annual U.S. LP sales dropped below 1 million units. Every format shift of the last five decades happened on the Montgomery Road storefront.
The shop also survived the rebuilding era. When vinyl sales began recovering around 2007 and grew year over year into the current revival, Everybody's was already there with nearly three decades of used stock, institutional knowledge, and a Cincinnati customer base that had never stopped shopping. That continuity is why the shop's current inventory is so deep: five decades of trade-ins, buys, and estate purchases have accumulated in the bins. A record that passed through a Cincinnati home in 1982 can still surface at Everybody's in 2026.
Five decades of format survival
Independent record stores in the U.S. peaked at roughly 10,000 shops in the late 1970s. By 2006, fewer than 1,000 remained. The shops that survived that contraction are a rare breed, and Everybody's Records is one of them. Cincinnati kept its independent record anchor through the format shifts that closed the rest.
Pleasant Ridge and the Montgomery Road Corridor
Pleasant Ridge is a residential and small-business neighborhood on the northeast side of Cincinnati, roughly 15 minutes northeast of downtown via I-71 or Reading Road. The Pleasant Ridge Business District along Montgomery Road hosts Everybody's Records alongside neighborhood restaurants, cafes, and independent shops. The adjacent Golf Manor community shares the Montgomery Road corridor and brings its own customer base to the block.
Unlike Northside's Hamilton Avenue (home to Shake It Records) or Ludlow Avenue in Clifton (home to Feel It Records), Pleasant Ridge is not a destination commercial district. It is a neighborhood where people live, eat, and occasionally drive to run errands. Everybody's works in that context precisely because it does not depend on foot traffic or tourist draw. The shop runs on loyal regular customers, the kind of weekly visitors who have been shopping there since the 1980s or 1990s.
What to Dig For
Everybody's Records carries a broad general-interest inventory rather than a narrow genre focus. The bins run wide across:
- Classic rock. Decades of used turnover means the classic rock section is unusually deep. Led Zeppelin, Fleetwood Mac, Pink Floyd, The Who, and the broader canon stocked in multiple pressings.
- Soul and R&B. Cincinnati's musical heritage (King Records, James Brown, Bootsy Collins) runs through the soul bins. Motown, Stax, and the broader Black music canon stocked deep.
- Jazz. Blue Note, Impulse, Prestige, and smaller independent jazz labels. Late hours make it the easy after-work jazz stop.
- Country and folk. Often underrepresented in trendier indie shops; Everybody's has the classic country and folk depth that only accumulated used stock produces.
- Classical. A genuine classical vinyl section, which is rare in modern record stores. Budget LP classical and the occasional collector pressing.
- New releases. A steady rotation of new vinyl at the front of the store. Not competing with Shake It on label depth, but carrying the titles neighborhood customers want.
- CDs and music-related merchandise. Still stocked for the customers who have never left the CD format.
The curatorial lane is general Cincinnati neighborhood record store, not specialist audiophile or single-genre deep dive. That positioning is the reason Everybody's has survived every era: the shop serves the Pleasant Ridge and broader east-side Cincinnati community rather than chasing any single collector demographic.
Why the Late Hours Matter
Most Cincinnati record stores close by 6 or 7 pm. Everybody's stays open until 9 pm Monday through Saturday. That is the shop's quiet competitive advantage: you can hit Everybody's after work at 7:30, after dinner at 8:15, or on a Saturday night when every other shop in the city has closed. For Cincinnati residents who work day jobs and for out-of-town visitors whose afternoon schedules got swallowed by something else, the 9 pm close means Everybody's remains the accessible option long after the other anchors have locked up.
Saturday hours especially pair well with a Cincinnati weekend. Start at Shake It Records in Northside around opening, lunch on Hamilton Avenue, head to Plaid Room Records in Loveland for the afternoon, and close the day at Everybody's on Montgomery Road with Pleasant Ridge dinner options nearby. Four shops, four neighborhoods, one day.
Plan Your Visit
Everybody's Records
Cincinnati's longest-running independent record store. Open since 1978. Montgomery Road in Pleasant Ridge. Late hours. Deep used vinyl.
Phone: (513) 531-4500
Hours: Mon-Fri 11am-9pm, Sat 10am-9pm, Sun 12pm-6pm
Web: everybodysrecords.com
Facebook: Everybody's Records on Facebook
Getting there
Everybody's Records is at 6106 Montgomery Road in Pleasant Ridge, roughly 15 minutes northeast of downtown Cincinnati via I-71 or Reading Road. From the Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky International Airport (CVG), the drive is about 30 minutes. Free parking is available in the Pleasant Ridge Business District and on the side streets adjacent to the shop. The shop is accessible via Cincinnati Metro bus routes that run along Montgomery Road.
Make a day of it
Pair Everybody's with a Pleasant Ridge meal or coffee before or after your visit. The Pleasant Ridge Business District has restaurants, a brewery, and small-business food options within a few blocks. For the full Cincinnati four-shop dig, pair with Shake It Records (Northside, mornings), Feel It Records (Ludlow Avenue, afternoon), and Plaid Room Records (Loveland, 35 minutes northeast). Everybody's 9 pm close makes it the natural finish of the day.
Plan a Cincinnati Record Weekend
Full guide to every independent record store in Cincinnati, with a one-day dig plan and drive times between shops.
Best Record Stores in CincinnatiDiscover Your Next Favorite Shop
New store features, hidden gems, and community stories from record stores across the country.
Everybody's Records FAQ
Montgomery Road, Pleasant Ridge, five decades of Cincinnati vinyl. Everybody's is the neighborhood anchor that format shifts could not kill.
