The best record stores in Madison punch well above the city's population thanks to a combination of UW-Madison student foot traffic, a strong local music culture, and four-plus decades of continuous indie record retail. Three anchors spread across three walkable neighborhoods: Monroe Street on the near west side for the flagship, State Street between downtown and campus for Madison's longest-running independent, and Atwood Avenue on the east side for the Williamson-turned-Atwood used specialist. Pair with a Wisconsin State Capitol tour, a Memorial Union lakeshore walk, or a Williamson Street brewery afternoon, and Madison is one of the better Midwest record-weekend cities.
This guide covers every active independent brick-and-mortar record store in Madison with addresses, hours, specialties, and a one-day plan that hits all three anchors. The lakes are real. The campus is walkable. The vinyl scene runs deeper than most out-of-town visitors expect.
Strictly Discs
Strictly Discs
Phone: (608) 259-1991
Hours: Mon-Thu 10am-6pm, Fri 10am-8pm, Sat 10am-6pm, Sun 11am-5pm
Web: strictlydiscs.com
Online store: shop.strictlydiscs.com
Facebook: Strictly Discs on Facebook
Strictly Discs on Monroe Street is the Madison flagship and the biggest single-shop catalog in the Wisconsin capital. The shop carries new and used vinyl, CDs, cassettes, and HiFi equipment, and runs a full e-commerce storefront at shop.strictlydiscs.com alongside the brick-and-mortar. That e-commerce infrastructure is unusual for a Midwest indie; it extends the used inventory beyond what fits on the Monroe Street floor and makes Strictly Discs a national rather than regional seller.
For Madison locals, Strictly Discs is the go-to for new release day. For traveling collectors, the Monroe Street store rewards a methodical browse because the used catalog runs far deeper than a first-time visitor would guess. The HiFi side is the kicker: few record stores still stock turntables and cartridges at this level, and the Strictly Discs HiFi section is a legitimate reason to visit even if you are not buying a record that day.
What to dig for: deep used LP catalog, new releases on first pressing, cassettes for the format collectors, HiFi equipment (turntables, cartridges, styluses), and Record Store Day exclusives at the Madison RSD anchor.
B-Side Records
B-Side Records
Phone: (608) 255-1977
Hours: Mon-Thu 10am-6pm, Fri-Sat 10am-7pm, Sun 11am-5pm
Web: b-sidemadison.com
Facebook: B-Side on Facebook
B-Side Records at 514 State Street has been running since 1982. Over four decades on Madison's State Street corridor makes B-Side Wisconsin's longest-tenured independent record store and one of the longest-running in the Upper Midwest. The State Street location sits in the middle of the pedestrian mall between the Wisconsin State Capitol and the UW-Madison campus, which has made it a default college-town record stop for generations of Badgers.
The shop's tagline, "new, classic, and uncommon music since 1982," is accurate. B-Side stocks CDs, DVDs, and vinyl across every genre, and the staff's institutional memory is the kind that only four decades of continuous buying produces. For collectors chasing unusual pressings, B-Side regularly surfaces things newer shops have never seen.
What to dig for: uncommon pressings from four decades of local buying, deep catalog across rock, jazz, soul, and experimental, CDs and DVDs alongside vinyl, and the kind of staff recommendations that come from running a State Street shop since before half your customers were born.
Find More Record Stores in Wisconsin
Browse every independent record store we have mapped across the Badger State.
Wisconsin Record Store DirectoryMadCity Music
MadCity Music
Phone: (608) 251-8558
Hours: Mon-Sat 11am-5pm, Sun 11am-4pm
Web: madcitymusic.net
Facebook: MadCity Music on Facebook
MadCity Music sits on Atwood Avenue on Madison's east side, in a neighborhood that runs independent business culture as seriously as any block in the Upper Midwest. The shop previously operated on Williamson Street and moved to Atwood in 2017, keeping the same used-turnover model that built its reputation. Where Strictly Discs leans flagship-and-HiFi and B-Side leans four-decade-catalog, MadCity Music leans weekly-used-turnover.
For regulars who stop in weekly, MadCity is where the interesting used material surfaces. The shop's buying relationships with Madison collectors and the steady flow of estate and collection-shrinkage trade-ins mean the racks change faster than the other two anchors. Bring a want list, check what is in the bins today, and plan to come back next week.
What to dig for: weekly-rotating used LPs, collections that surface from Madison estate buys, CDs and DVDs alongside vinyl, east-side independent vibe, and the kind of low-friction browse that rewards a quick visit before dinner at a Williamson Street restaurant.
Also Worth a Stop
Beyond the three main anchors, Madison's record scene rotates newer shops into and out of the market. A few to keep on radar:
- Strictly Discs Cambridge warehouse. Strictly Discs maintains a second retail location at its Cambridge, WI warehouse (101 W Main St, Cambridge). Open Wednesday through Sunday. Worth the 25-minute drive east for the deep used inventory that does not fit the Monroe Street floor.
- Resale shops on State and Willy. Madison's thrift and general-resale culture occasionally surfaces vinyl. Not a substitute for the three anchors, but worth a peek if you are walking the neighborhoods.
- Record Store Day pop-ups. Madison's indie music community occasionally runs RSD-adjacent events in spring and fall. Check the Isthmus Vinyl Cave column for current.
Worth the Drive
The Upper Midwest rewards a longer trip if Madison has been dug:
- Milwaukee, WI (90 minutes east). Larger scene anchored by Exclusive Company (historic), plus newer independents.
- Minneapolis / St. Paul, MN (4 hours west). The Twin Cities vinyl flagship scene with Electric Fetus and a dozen others.
- Chicago, IL (2.5 hours south). The Midwest's record store capital with dozens of active indies.
- Iowa City, IA (3.5 hours southwest). College-town scene with Record Collector and Daydreams.
- Des Moines, IA (4 hours southwest). See our Des Moines area guide for the Iowa capital scene.
The One-Day Madison Dig
Three shops fit a single Saturday with time for the Capitol Square and a lake walk:
- 10 a.m. Strictly Discs (1900 Monroe St). Opens earliest. Budget 90 minutes. Hit the HiFi side even if you are not buying. The section is worth seeing.
- 11:45 a.m. Drive to State Street (10 minutes). Park once near the Capitol; State Street is pedestrian-only.
- 12 p.m. B-Side Records (514 State St). Budget 75 minutes. Walk the State Street pedestrian mall afterward for lunch and coffee.
- 2 p.m. Lunch. State Street has options. Ian's Pizza is obligatory if you have never had it.
- 3 p.m. Drive to Atwood Avenue (15 minutes east across the isthmus).
- 3:15 p.m. MadCity Music (2023 Atwood Ave). 45 to 60 minutes. Walk the Atwood corridor after for a brewery or a restaurant.
- Evening. Capitol Square, Memorial Union Terrace for the lake, or dinner on Willy Street.
Tips for Digging Madison
- Winter is cold enough to matter for vinyl. Do not leave records in a car below freezing. Vinyl can crack. See our vinyl storage guide.
- State Street is pedestrian-only. Park in a garage near the Capitol and walk. B-Side is mid-mall.
- Strictly Discs e-commerce. If you are not making the trip and still want access to the Monroe Street used catalog, shop.strictlydiscs.com ships nationally.
- Record Store Day at Strictly Discs is the Madison anchor event. Line forms early.
- Protect your haul. Lake-Madison summer humidity is real even in the Upper Midwest. Store properly.
Browse the Full Directory
Every independent record store in the U.S., organized by state.
Record Store DirectoryGet More Record Store Guides
New Spin City city guides, featured shops, and vinyl news delivered to your inbox.
Madison Record Store FAQ
Isthmus, lakes, Capitol, vinyl. Madison earns the Midwest trip.
